The Danger of the Monoculture: I Timothy 4:11-16

11Command and teach these things. 12Let no one despise you for your youth, but set the believers an example in speech, in conduct, in love, in faith, in purity. 13Until I come, devote yourself to the public reading of Scripture, to exhortation, to teaching. 14Do not neglect the gift you have, which was given you by prophecy when the council of elders laid their hands on you. 15Practice these things, devote yourself to them, so that all may see your progress. 16Keep a close watch on yourself and on the teaching. Persist in this, for by so doing you will save both yourself and your hearers.

Paul begins chapter four with the warning “that in later times some will depart from the faith by devoting themselves to deceitful spirits and teachings of demons” because their consciences have been made numb as if being seared by a hot iron. The proponents of the ecumenical monoculture and postmodern Christianity have abandoned Christ and his teachings and in turn devoted themselves to the teachings of demons. We live in that time, in verse three Paul even lists several popular false doctrines currently taught at Ephesus. The ecumenical monoculture and postmodern Christianity claims that doctrine and theology are unimportant, however, I Timothy offers several reasons why this just is not so.

v.11 Biblical Christianity and the monoculture clash over this issue. The monoculture asks, “Why, if we are all on our own spiritual journey should one man stand and speak with authority?” The pastor exists to shepherd, lead, and protect God’s flock, not merely to journey with it. A good pastor will command and teach the Word of God. The fulfillment of The Great Commission (Matthew 28:16-20) is dependent upon teaching the nations to obey God’s Word. God is not an inert spiritual being; He is a despotic ruler (Acts 4) of absolute power who demands your obedience.

v.13 A good pastor devotes himself to three things. First, a good pastor must devote himself to the public reading of Scripture. Cashing in on Biblical illiteracy, many are abandoning the public reading of Scripture for skits, video clips, and stories. Any authority the pastor has is derived from God’s Word and apart from this the pastor has no authority. Second, a good pastor must devote himself to exhortation. Exhortation refers to the application of God’s word; this could take the form of a command to obey and submit, encouragement to persevere, comfort, or rebuke. Third, a good pastor must devote himself to teaching, also translated doctrine. The current trend of teaching anecdotal stories and pop psychology is abhorrently unbiblical. The pastor must systematically exposit God’s Word.

v.14 Paul is referring to Timothy’s spiritual gifts, to be used in ministry, of preaching/teaching, and evangelism. Through abandoning Christ and devoting themselves to demonic doctrines, the proponents of the monoculture and postmodern Christianity have no spiritual gifts. However, this passage exhorts Biblical pastors, and every Christian, to stay the course, to be doctrinally sound, and to use you spiritual gifts.

v.15 Paul continues his exhortation encouraging every good pastor to devote himself to these things to the point that all may see their progress. Quite simply others should notice your obedience to God’s Word.

v.16 This verse offers a promise from God coupled with an extremely severe warning. Perseverance in the Truth is a mark of genuine conversion and the pastor who perseveres in teaching sound doctrine can be used by God as an instrument to deliver the Gospel that God might save some (see John 8:31 and Romans 10:9-17). The pastor must persevere in two areas his teaching/doctrine and his conduct; he must teach and live the truth and because of this God will save some. The warning and the danger of the monoculture is this: the abandonment of Biblical doctrine is tantamount to abandoning Christ and the congregation who bases their salvation upon the doctrines of demons will not be saved. The monoculture wants to downplay the importance of doctrinal beliefs posing that they are unimportant, unnecessary, and should be abandoned to promote unity, ecumenism. This is a damning lie; sound doctrine is of the utmost importance because without the preaching of the true Word of Christ no one can be saved (Romans 10:9-17).


3 thoughts on “The Danger of the Monoculture: I Timothy 4:11-16

  1. Keith,

    I have read all of your posts and I am highly impressed. For the most part, aside from all the intelligent stuff you wrote, I would think I authored this blog.

    Ecumenical Monoculture is a wonderful descriptive of what is happening and has been happening for years. However, I warn you to be careful. If you continue down the path you are on, you will end up on the outside of mainstream modern Christianity, as I have been for several years now, and everyone will be upset about it, including your own family.

    The only way to have a positive monoculture is to end the denominational divisions by ending the denominations and everyone simply doing what the Bible says. Keep in mind, on the day of Pentecost there were no Roman Catholics, there were no Protestants. There were only Christians and they were members of nothing more or less than Christ’s church.

    Theoretically, we can have that again, but not while the denominational division continues.

    I look forward to more of your insight on the Ecumenical Monoculture and hope we can spend some time together with a Bible in our hands helping each other understand exactly what God’s original intent with the Bible was. That is all I have ever wanted to follow and is all I want to do even now.

    I love you and your willingness to boldly state what you believe, even though it is unpopular.

    Your devoted cousin

  2. Hey, glad to hear that you have enjoyed everything so far. I will keep an eye on your blog too.

    I really hope I am already outside of modern Christianity :) I think the obsession over modernity has had devastating affects on the Church. The primary concern of Christians should be the Church 2000 years ago and how to emulate the Christ. Not the abandonment of scripture in exchange for cleverness.

    I wish there could be a Biblical monoculture, where everyone embraces God’s Word in its entireity. However, I think that as the independant church movement has shown men are evil, deceptive, and easily swayed.

    It is my conviction that denominations provide a means of accountability to hold pastors and their congregations to a Biblical standard; that is of course if their denomination is founded upon Biblical standards. With many denominations promoting the ordination of homosexual pastors, among other absurdities, it is clear that not all denominations are Biblical.

  3. Interesting thought about denominations and accountability.

    I have several questions based on your thought and what you have said about the monoculture. How many denominations can actually be based on the Bible standard all at the same time? If we accept more than one and just agree to disagree on the issues that divide is that not just another stepping stone to the Ecumenical Monoculture you rightly rebuke?

    Also, how far does that accountability issue go? Who holds the higher ups accountable? For instance, in the Catholic church the priests are held accountable by the bishops, they are held accountable by archbishops and so on until they are held accountable by the college of Cardinals and then the Pope. But who holds the Pope accountable? As far as I have seen, the organization of Protestant churches is only a variation on the Catholic theme?

    Finally, and this is a discussion question to provoke thought and conversation–since the denomination is to be based on biblical standards to be beneficial, where is the Biblical standard upon which the denominational organization itself is based?

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s